Please Log in / Register to access the full text of this judgment and the entire database
(2026) Law Today Live Doc. Id. 21588 = 2026:PHHC:194186
Decided on: 02.11.2026
Present:
Mr. Aditya Dassaur, Advocate for the appellants.
Mr. Sandeep Jain, Advocate with Mr. Sachin Jain, Advocate with Mr. Davinder Kumar, Advocate for the respondent No.1.
Respondent No.2 proceeded ex-parte vide order dated 15.07.2016.
***
Joint Tubewell Connection – Co-ownership – Right to Draw Water – A co-owner is entitled to draw water from a tubewell installed for jointly owned agricultural land in proportion to his proprietary share, and another co-owner cannot obstruct the exercise of such lawful entitlement.
***
Punjab Courts Act, 1918 (VI of 1918), Section 41 – Regular Second Appeal – Co-ownership – Joint Tubewell Connection – Right to Draw Water – Equitable Use – Plaintiff and defendants were co-owners of agricultural land served by a jointly installed tubewell connection – Plaintiff claimed entitlement to draw water to the extent of 2/3rd share, while the appellant disputed the same and asserted equal contribution towards installation – Held, the right of co-owners to draw water through a tubewell installed for jointly owned agricultural land must correspond to their respective proprietary shares in the land served by the facility – A co-owner cannot obstruct another co-owner from exercising the lawful right to draw water to the extent of his established share – First Appellate Court rightly declared the plaintiff’s entitlement to draw water to the extent of 2/3rd share – No illegality or material infirmity warranting interference – Regular Second Appeal dismissed.
(Paras 7–10.1)
Cases referred:
1. Pankajakshi (Dead) through LRs and others Vs. Chandrika and others, (2016)6 SCC 157.
2. Kirodi (since deceased) through his LR Vs. Ram Parkash and others, (2019) 11 SCC 317.
3. Satender and others Vs. Saroj and others, 2022(12) Scale 92.
***
VIRINDER AGGARWAL, J. –
1. The appellant-defendant No. 2 has preferred the present Regular Second Appeal (‘RSA’ for short), assailing the judgment and decree dated 29.10.2015 passed by the District Judge, Shaheed Bhagat Singh Nagar, which partly modified the judgment and decree dated 19.01.2015 passed by the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Shaheed Bhagat Singh Nagar. The appellant seeks setting aside of both judgments and decrees and dismissal of the suit, contending that the impugned decisions suffer from manifest errors of law, perversity and misappreciation of the evidence, resulting in a miscarriage of justice.
2. Brief facts of the present case are that the plaintiff instituted the suit asserting that his father, Des Raj, held tubewell connection No. B-159 over jointly owned land. Upon inheritance and purchase of the shares of Babu Ram’s legal heirs on 20.08.1990, the plaintiff and his brother acquired a 2/3 share in the connection, while the defendants retained a 1/3rd share through their predecessor, Karam Chand. Alleging obstruction by the defendants in exercising his co-ownership rights, the plaintiff sought the requisite relief.
3. The defendants contested the suit on grounds of maintainability and non-joinder of necessary parties, while admitting the respective 1/3rd shares of Karam Chand, Des Raj and Babu Ram and succession thereto. They disputed the plaintiff’s 2/3rd share in the tubewell connection, asserting equal co-ownership, as the original tubewell was jointly installed in 1982, sold in 2005, and replaced in 2006 at equal expense. Accordingly, they sought dismissal of the suit.
4. Upon consideration of the pleadings and evidence on record, the Trial Court framed the following issues for adjudication:-
1.Whether the plaintiff is the owner to the extent of 2/3rd in the motor connection in dispute? OPP
2.Whether the plaintiff is entitled to relief as prayed for? OPP
3.Whether the present suit is not maintainable? OPD
4.Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties? OPD
5.Whether the plaintiff has no cause of action to file the present suit? OPD
6.Relief.
5. Both parties were afforded due opportunity to adduce evidence. Upon conclusion of the trial and consideration of the rival submissions, the Trial Court decreed the suit with costs, restraining the defendants from obstructing the plaintiff’s use of the tubewell connection for irrigating his land, except in accordance with law.
6. Although the Trial Court decreed the suit for permanent injunction, the plaintiff preferred an appeal, aggrieved by its failure to determine the respective shares of the parties in the use of tube-well connection. While the Trial Court considered adjudication of title unnecessary in a suit for injunction simpliciter, the plaintiff contended that determination of the parties’ respective shares was essential to ascertain their entitlement to draw water from the joint tube-well connection. The First Appellate Court accepted this contention, observing that a decree permitting use of the tube-well, without specifying the extent of such entitlement, would remain incomplete and ineffective. Accordingly, while substantially affirming the findings of the Trial Court, the First Appellate Court partly allowed the appeal and declared the right of the plaintiff, along with his brother, to draw water from the tube-well connection to the extent of 2/3 rd share.
6.1. Aggrieved by the findings recorded by the First Appellate Court, appellant-defendant No. 2 has preferred the present Regular Second Appeal. Upon admission of the appeal, notice was issued to the respondents, who entered appearance through counsel and contested the appeal, whereas respondent No. 2 was proceeded against ex parte vide order dated 15.07.2016. The records of the Courts below were requisitioned for examination and consideration.
7. As regards the scope of second appeal, it is now a settled proposition of law that in Punjab and Haryana, second appeals preferred are to be treated as appeals under Section 41 of the Punjab Courts Act, 1918 and not under Section 100 CPC. Reference in this regard can be made to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Pankajakshi (Dead) through LRs and others Vs. Chandrika and others, (2016)6 SCC 157, followed by the judgments in the case of Kirodi (since deceased) through his LR Vs. Ram Parkash and others, (2019) 11 SCC 317 and Satender and others Vs. Saroj and others, 2022(12) Scale 92. Relying upon the law laid down in the aforesaid judgments, no question of law is required to be framed.
8.Learned counsel for the appellant-defendant No. 2 contended that both Courts below had misappreciated the evidence on record and failed to accord due weight to the material establishing the appellants’ claim of ½ share in the tube-well connection. It was argued that the purchase bills pertaining to its installation demonstrated that the expenses had been jointly borne by the parties. Learned counsel further submitted that, in a suit for permanent injunction simpliciter, the Courts below ought to have confined their adjudication to possession rather than delving into the question of title. Accordingly, it was urged that the impugned judgments and decrees be set aside and the suit filed by the respondents-plaintiffs be dismissed.
9. Per contra, learned counsel for respondent No.1-plaintiff defended the findings of the First Appellate Court, contending that the right to draw water from a tube-well installed for the benefit of jointly owned property must correspond to the respective proprietary shares of the parties. It was submitted that the First Appellate Court had rightly recognised the respondent-plaintiff’s entitlement to draw water to the extent of share and restrained the appellant-defendants from interfering? with the exercise of that right. Accordingly, dismissal of the appeal was sought.
10. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and, with their able assistance, having meticulously scrutinized the paper-book, this Court finds no justification to interfere with the findings recorded by the First Appellate Court. It is not in dispute that the tube-well connection was jointly installed by the parties for the irrigation of the jointly owned land, over which they continue to hold co-ownership rights. In such circumstances, the entitlement of the parties to draw water through the tube-well must be assessed in the context of their respective proprietary shares in the land served by the said facility. The First Appellate Court, having regard to the respondent-plaintiff’s ownership rights, has rightly recognized his entitlement to draw water to the extent of his share. The? said determination is neither arbitrary nor contrary to the material on record; rather, it proceeds on a rational and legally sustainable basis, commensurate with the respective interests of the parties in the jointly owned property.
10.1. It is equally pertinent to observe that water is an indispensable yet finite natural resource, warranting judicious utilization and equitable distribution amongst those legally entitled to its use. The right to draw water through a tube-well installed for the benefit of jointly owned agricultural land cannot be exercised so as to unjustifiably prejudice or curtail the corresponding rights of the other co-owners. Conversely, a co-owner whose proprietary interest is limited to a particular share cannot claim an unrestricted right to interfere with the lawful exercise of the rights of another co-owner beyond what is warranted by his own entitlement. Accordingly, the appellant-defendant, whose interest in the land is limited to his respective share, cannot be permitted to obstruct the respondent-plaintiff from drawing water through the tube-well to the extent of the latter’s established entitlement. The findings recorded by the First Appellate Court are, therefore, well-founded, legally sustainable and free from any illegality or material infirmity warranting interference in the present appeal. No substantial ground has been made out to disturb the impugned judgments and decrees. Consequently, the present appeal, being devoid of merit, is hereby dismissed.
11. In view of the final adjudication of the principal matter, all pending miscellaneous applications, if any, arising therefrom shall stand disposed of accordingly. No further orders are warranted in this regard.
Appeal dismissed.
********