Please Log in / Register to access the full text of this judgment and the entire database
(2026) Law Today Live Doc. Id. 21590 = 2026:PHHC:201238
Reserved on: 13.11.2026 Decided on: 16.11.2026
Along with
FAO-4589-2014 (O&M), Manpreet Singh Sood v. Rajiv Sharma and others
Present:
Mr. Rahul Pathania, Advocate for the appellant in FAO-2493-2014 and for respondent No.3 in FAO-4589-2014.
Mr. Maninder Jit Singh, Advocate for Mr. Amit Jaiswal, Advocate for respondent No.5 in FAO-4589-2014.
Mr. M.S. Sachdev, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Mehar Sachdev, Mr. Arsh Gupta and
Mr. Rahul Sharma, Advocates for the appellant in FAO-4589-2014 and for the respondents in FAO-2493-2014.
***
MACT -- Death Claim – Mere death of an injured person during pendency of a claim petition does not establish a causal connection with the accident; claimants must prove such connection through cogent medical evidence.
***
MACT – Composite Negligence – Mere involvement of a vehicle or its striking another vehicle from behind does not establish negligence; apportionment of liability between joint tortfeasors requires proof of negligence attributable to each.
***
A. Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (59 of 1988), Section 166 – Motor Accident Claims – Death Claim – Causal Connection Between Accident and Death – Injured, aged about 79 years, sustained serious head injuries in a motor accident and died approximately eight months later during pendency of the claim petition – Legal representatives sought conversion of the injury claim into a death claim – Held, mere occurrence of death during pendency of the claim petition does not establish that death resulted from accidental injuries – Claimants must prove a causal connection between the injuries and subsequent death through cogent medical evidence – In the absence of medical opinion, examination of the treating doctor or post-mortem report, the claim could not be treated as a death claim – However, legal representatives were entitled to pursue compensation for medical expenses, loss of earnings and other damages accrued to the injured during his lifetime.
(Paras 8–13)
B. Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (59 of 1988), Section 166 – Composite Negligence – Apportionment of Liability – Accident involved an Indica car which first collided with a truck and was subsequently hit from behind by a Bolero vehicle – Tribunal found negligence only on the part of the Indica car driver and exonerated the Bolero driver – Held, mere involvement of a vehicle in the collision or its striking another vehicle from behind does not, by itself, establish negligence – Before liability can be apportioned between joint tortfeasors, negligence attributable to each must first be established – In the absence of evidence establishing negligence of the Bolero driver, the insurer’s plea for apportionment of liability was rightly rejected.
(Paras 14–19)
C. Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (59 of 1988), Section 166 – Compensation – Personal Injuries – Pain and Suffering – Attendant Charges – Injured sustained serious head injuries involving intracranial bleeding, neurological complications and left-sided weakness and required assistance with daily activities – Held, compensation for pain and suffering must be just and reasonable, having regard to the nature of injuries, age and period of treatment – Assistance provided by family members cannot be excluded from consideration merely because no paid attendant was engaged – Compensation enhanced from Rs.5,000 to Rs.50,000 towards pain and suffering and Rs.24,000 awarded towards attendant charges at Rs.3,000 per month for eight months – Total compensation enhanced from Rs.3,65,423 to Rs.4,34,423, with interest at 7.5% per annum.
(Paras 20–26)
Cases referred:
1. The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kahlon @ Jasmail Singh Kahlon (deceased) through LRs and another, (2022) 13 SCC 494;
2. Khenyei v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. And others, (2015) 9 SCC 273;
3. Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar and another, (2011) 1 SCC 343
***
DEEPAK GUPTA, J. –
By this common order, the aforesaid two appeals, arising out of the award dated 01.03.2014 passed by learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Jalandhar (hereinafter referred to as 'the Tribunal'), are being disposed of. One appeal has been preferred by the claimant seeking enhancement of compensation, whereas the other has been filed by New India Assurance Company Limited, questioning the finding regarding negligence and seeking apportionment of liability between the insurers of the two vehicles involved in the accident.
2. Briefly, the facts are that on 07.11.2008, Surjit Singh Sood, an Advocate aged about 79 years, was travelling along with Satnam Kaur in an Indica car bearing registration No.PB-08-AP-6460, being driven by Rajiv Sharma. When the vehicle reached near Lamma Pind flyover, Jalandhar, it collided with a truck proceeding ahead. Thereafter, a Bolero vehicle bearing registration No.PB-30-D-3719, being driven by Gurpreet Singh, struck the Indica car from behind. Surjit Singh Sood sustained head injuries and was admitted to Satyam Hospital and Trauma Centre, Jalandhar.
3. Injured Surjit Singh Sood initially instituted a claim petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, seeking compensation for the injuries suffered by him. However, during pendency of the proceedings, he expired on 13.07.2009, whereafter his legal representatives pursued the claim petition, alleging that his death was attributable to the accidental injuries.
4. Learned Tribunal, upon appreciation of the evidence, held that the accident had occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the Indica car by respondent No.1 Rajiv Sharma. The driver of the Bolero vehicle was exonerated of negligence. The Tribunal further held that the claimants had failed to establish any causal connection between the injuries suffered in the accident and the subsequent death of Surjit Singh Sood. Accordingly, compensation was assessed only in respect of the injuries and consequential losses suffered by him during his lifetime, as under:
|
Head |
Compensation |
|
. Medical expenses, transportation, special diet and miscellaneous expenditure |
Rs. 2,40,423 |
|
. Loss of earnings for eight months |
Rs. 1,20,000 |
|
. Pain and suffering |
Rs. 5,000 |
|
Total |
Rs. 3,65,423 |
The amount was awarded along with interest @ 7.5% per annum from the date of institution of the claim petition till realization, with liability fastened jointly and severally upon the driver, owner and insurer of the Indica car.
5.1 Learned counsel appearing for the claimants submits that the Tribunal erred in declining to treat the claim petition as one arising out of the death of Surjit Singh Sood, particularly when he had sustained serious head injuries in the accident and subsequently expired during pendency of the proceedings. It is contended that the claim petition had been duly amended by the legal representatives seeking compensation on account of death and, therefore, the claim ought to have been assessed accordingly.
5.2 However, during the course of arguments, learned counsel fairly concedes that there is no connecting medical evidence establishing that the death occurred as a consequence of the accidental injuries. It is further conceded that neither the treating doctor was examined nor any medical opinion establishing such connection was produced. Learned counsel nevertheless relies upon the discharge summary, Mark-A, to highlight the serious nature of the injuries sustained by Surjit Singh Sood.
5.3 Alternatively, it is contended that even if the claim is confined to the injuries suffered during his lifetime, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is inadequate, particularly under the heads of pain & suffering and attendant charges. It is submitted that the injured suffered serious neurological complications and remained dependent upon others for his daily activities, but the Tribunal awarded only Rs.5,000 towards pain and suffering and nothing towards attendant charges. Enhancement under these heads is accordingly sought.
6. On the other hand, learned counsel representing the appellant-insurance company submits that the accident involved two vehicles, namely, the Indica car and the Bolero vehicle. It is contended that the Indica car initially collided with the truck proceeding ahead and thereafter the Bolero vehicle struck it from behind. According to learned counsel, the driver of the Bolero vehicle was also negligent in failing to maintain a safe distance and exercise due care. It is, therefore, argued that the Tribunal erred in fastening the entire liability upon the driver, owner and insurer of the Indica car. A prayer is made for apportionment of liability between the insurers of both vehicles.
7. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and examined the impugned award as well as the material available on record, this Court finds that the appeals require consideration on three aspects, namely, (i) whether the claim petition deserves to be treated as a death claim, (ii) whether the finding regarding negligence calls for interference and (iii) whether the compensation awarded under the injury-related heads requires enhancement.
8. Firstly, insofar as the prayer of the claimants to treat the claim petition as a death claim is concerned, it is undisputed that Surjit Singh Sood sustained head injuries in the accident dated 07.11.2008 and subsequently expired on 13.07.2009. However, the fact that death occurred approximately eight months after the accident does not, by itself, establish that it was caused by the accidental injuries. The burden to prove such causal connection was upon the claimants.
9. The discharge summary, Mark-A, records that Surjit Singh Sood was admitted to Satyam Hospital on 08.11.2008 with a history of road traffic accident. The MRI findings disclosed an acute right fronto-temporo-parietooccipital subdural haematoma, with extension into the posterior interhemispheric fissure, besides a large non-haemorrhagic infarct in the right posterior cerebral artery territory. The patient was also noted to have left-sided hemiparesis. The document further records pre-existing medical conditions, including ischaemic heart disease, atrial fibrillation and hypertension.
10. Although the aforesaid medical record indicates that the injured had suffered significant neurological complications, it does not establish that his subsequent death on 13.07.2009 was attributable to those injuries. Neither the treating doctor was examined nor was any medical opinion produced explaining the cause of death. Admittedly, no post-mortem examination was conducted. The medical record relating to treatment in November 2008 cannot, without further connecting evidence, be treated as sufficient proof of the cause of death occurring several months thereafter. The concession made by learned counsel for the claimants is also consistent with this evidentiary position.
11. Merely because the injured died during pendency of the claim petition and his legal representatives amended the pleadings to seek compensation on account of death, it cannot be presumed that the death was the direct consequence of the accidental injuries. For treating the claim as one arising out of death, it was incumbent upon the claimants to establish a causal connection between the injuries sustained in the accident and the subsequent death. In the absence of such evidence, the mere sequence of events, coupled with the oral assertions of the legal representatives, is insufficient to establish the requisite causal relationship.
12. Consequently, the prayer to treat the claim petition as a death claim is declined. The finding recorded by the Tribunal in this regard is affirmed.
13. Nevertheless, the absence of proof connecting death with the accident does not disentitle the legal representatives from pursuing compensation for the losses suffered by the injured during his lifetime. The claim petition had originally been instituted by Surjit Singh Sood himself. His legal representatives are entitled to pursue the claim for medical expenditure, loss of earnings during treatment and other damages, which had accrued to him on account of the injuries. The principle governing survival of such a claim has been explained by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Kahlon @ Jasmail Singh Kahlon (deceased) through LRs and another, (2022) 13 SCC 494.
14. Coming to the appeal preferred by the insurance company, the evidence establishes that the Indica car initially collided with the truck proceeding ahead of it. PW-1 Satnam Kaur, who was travelling in the Indica car, specifically testified that its driver was driving rashly and negligently and did not heed the warning given by the occupants. The driver, Rajiv Sharma, while appearing as RW-1, denied even having driven the vehicle or the occurrence of the accident. However, his version stood contradicted by DDR No.13 dated 07.11.2008, proved through PW-4 HC Kuldeep Singh, wherein the occurrence of the accident involving the Indica car, the truck and the Bolero vehicle had been recorded.
15. As regards the Bolero vehicle, its driver Gurpreet Singh, while appearing as RW-2, explained that the Indica car had suddenly stopped after colliding with the truck and that despite applying brakes, he could not avoid the subsequent collision. The Tribunal noticed that PW-1 Satnam Kaur was looking towards the front and had not observed the manner in which the Bolero vehicle was being driven. She was consequently unable to state its speed or the circumstances immediately preceding the collision from behind.
16. Merely because the Bolero vehicle struck the Indica car from behind, negligence on the part of its driver cannot automatically be presumed. Although every driver is required to maintain a reasonable distance from the vehicle proceeding ahead, the question whether such duty was breached must be determined in the light of the surrounding circumstances. In the present case, the Indica car had already collided with the truck and come to a halt. The evidence does not satisfactorily establish that the driver of the Bolero vehicle was travelling at an excessive speed, or that he had sufficient opportunity to avoid the collision despite exercising reasonable care.
17. The distinction between contributory negligence and composite negligence is also material. Contributory negligence arises where the injured person himself contributes to the occurrence of the accident, whereas composite negligence involves negligent acts of two or more persons resulting in injury to a third person. In Khenyei v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. And others, (2015) 9 SCC 273, the Hon'ble Supreme Court explained that in a case of composite negligence, the claimant is entitled to recover the entire compensation from any of the joint tortfeasors, and the question of apportionment arises in the manner indicated therein. However, before liability can be apportioned between different tortfeasors, negligence attributable to each must first be established.
18. In the present case, Surjit Singh Sood was an occupant of the Indica car and there is no allegation that he contributed to the accident. Thus, the plea, properly understood, is one of composite negligence rather than contributory negligence. The Tribunal, after appreciating the evidence of PW-1, RW-1 and RW-2, has returned a finding that negligence was established only against the driver of the Indica car. The mere involvement of the Bolero vehicle in the collision does not, by itself, justify fastening liability upon its driver or insurer. No material infirmity or perversity in the said finding has been demonstrated.
19. Consequently, the insurance company's prayer for apportionment of liability is declined.
20. Coming to the claimant's prayer for enhancement of compensation, the Tribunal has already awarded Rs.2,20,423 towards medical expenditure, Rs.20,000 towards transportation, special diet and miscellaneous expenses, and Rs. 1,20,000 towards loss of earnings for eight months, after accepting the monthly income of the injured as Rs. 15,000. These amounts are supported by the evidence considered by the Tribunal. No further enhancement under these heads is called for.
21. However, the award of merely Rs. 5,000 towards pain and suffering appears inadequate, considering the nature of the injuries suffered by Surjit Singh Sood. The discharge summary reflects a serious head injury involving intracranial bleeding, neurological complications and weakness of the left side of the body. The injured was about 79 years of age and had undergone hospitalization and treatment. The physical pain, mental trauma and discomfort associated with such injuries cannot be overlooked merely because medical evidence connecting his eventual death with the accident is unavailable.
22. In Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar and another, (2011) 1 SCC 343, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has explained that compensation in personal injury cases must be just and reasonable and should account for both pecuniary and non-pecuniary losses. Pain, suffering and trauma constitute an independent head of compensation. Keeping in view the nature of the injuries, age of the injured and period of treatment, this Court considers it appropriate to enhance compensation under the head of pain and suffering from Rs. 5,000 to Rs. 50,000.
23. As regards attendant charges, the claimants have specifically pleaded that Surjit Singh Sood required assistance for his daily activities after the accident. The medical record indicating left-sided hemiparesis lends support to the need for assistance, at least during the period of recovery and treatment. It is settled that the requirement of an attendant cannot be rejected merely because assistance was provided by a family member rather than a paid attendant. The value of such services is compensable, subject to a reasonable assessment based on the evidence.
24. Considering the advanced age of the injured, the nature of his neurological injuries and the period of approximately eight months between the accident and his death, this Court finds it appropriate to award Rs.24,000 towards attendant charges, calculated at Rs.3,000 per month for eight months. This amount represents a reasonable assessment of the assistance required by the injured and does not involve any duplication of the amounts already awarded towards medical treatment, transportation and special diet.
25. Consequently, the compensation is reassessed as follows:
|
Head |
Compensation |
|
. Medical expenses, transportation, special diet and miscellaneous expenditure |
Rs. 2,20,423 |
|
. Transportation, special diet and miscellaneous expenses |
Rs. 20,000 |
|
. Loss of earnings for eight months |
Rs. 1,20,000 |
|
. Pain and suffering |
Rs. 50,000 |
|
. Attendant charges |
Rs. 24,000 |
|
Total |
Rs. 4,34,423 |
26. Thus, against the compensation of Rs. 3,65,423 awarded by the Tribunal, the claimants are held entitled to Rs. 4,34,423/-, resulting in an enhancement of Rs. 69,000. The enhanced amount shall carry interest @ 7.5% per annum from the date of institution of the claim petition till realization, as awarded by the Tribunal. The directions regarding disbursement of the original compensation shall remain undisturbed. The enhanced amount shall be disbursed amongst the legal representatives in accordance with their shares determined by the Tribunal.
27. In view of the foregoing discussion, the appeal preferred by New India Assurance Company Limited, seeking apportionment of liability, is dismissed, whereas the appeal preferred by the claimants is partly allowed to the extent of enhancement of compensation indicated above. The impugned award dated 01.03.2014 stands modified accordingly.
28. Both appeals stand disposed of in the aforesaid terms. All pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall also stand disposed of. A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of connected case.
Order accordingly.
********